比特币白皮书
Bitcoin:APeer-to-PeerElectronicCashSystem
SatoshiNakamoto
satoshin@gmx.com
www.bitcoin.org
Abstract
Bitcoin:APeer-to-PeerElectronicCashSystem
SatoshiNakamoto
satoshin@gmx.com
www.bitcoin.org
1.Introduction
CommerceontheInternethascometorelyalmostexclusivelyonfinancialinstitutionsservingastrustedthirdpartiestoprocesselectronicpayments.Whilethesystemworkswellenoughformosttransactions,itstillsuffersfromtheinherentweaknessesofthetrustbasedmodel.Completelynon-reversibletransactionsarenotreallypossible,sincefinancialinstitutionscannotavoidmediatingdisputes.Thecostofmediationincreasestransactioncosts,limitingtheminimumpracticaltransactionsizeandcuttingoffthepossibilityforsmallcasualtransactions,andthereisabroadercostinthelossofabilitytomakenon-reversiblepaymentsfornonreversibleservices.Withthepossibilityofreversal,theneedfortrustspreads.Merchantsmustbewaryoftheircustomers,hasslingthemformoreinformationthantheywouldotherwiseneed.Acertainpercentageoffraudisacceptedasunavoidable.Thesecostsandpaymentuncertaintiescanbeavoidedinpersonbyusingphysicalcurrency,butnomechanismexiststomakepaymentsoveracommunicationschannelwithoutatrustedparty.
Whatisneededisanelectronicpaymentsystembasedoncryptographicproofinsteadoftrust,allowinganytwowillingpartiestotransactdirectlywitheachotherwithouttheneedforatrustedthirdparty.Transactionsthatarecomputationallyimpracticaltoreversewouldprotectsellersfromfraud,androutineescrowmechanismscouldeasilybeimplementedtoprotectbuyers.Inthispaper,weproposeasolutiontothedouble-spendingproblemusingapeer-to-peerdistributedtimestampservertogeneratecomputationalproofofthechronologicalorderoftransactions.ThesystemissecureaslongashonestnodescollectivelycontrolmoreCPUpowerthananycooperatinggroupofattackernodes.
2.Transactions
Wedefineanelectroniccoinasachainofdigitalsignatures.Eachownertransfersthecointothenextbydigitallysigningahashoftheprevioustransactionandthepublickeyofthenextownerandaddingthesetotheendofthecoin.Apayeecanverifythesignaturestoverifythechainofownership.
EigenLayer将推出首个主动验证服务EigenDA:金色财经报道，以太坊再质押协议EigenLayer在其推文中宣布将推出首个主动验证服务（AVS）\"EigenDA，该团队表示，将在未来几个月内在测试网上推出对EigenDA的访问，主网将在不久后推出。
据悉，EigenDA是一种数据可用性服务，可提供高交易处理量并通过以太坊运营商和 retakers 获得经济安全。水平扩展将使EigenDA最终能够以最小的成本和技术成本扩展至1 TB/s。[2023/8/29 13:02:43]
Theproblemofcourseisthepayeecan'tverifythatoneoftheownersdidnotdouble-spendthecoin.Acommonsolutionistointroduceatrustedcentralauthority,ormint,thatcheckseverytransactionfordoublespending.Aftereachtransaction,thecoinmustbereturnedtotheminttoissueanewcoin,andonlycoinsissueddirectlyfromthemintaretrustednottobedouble-spent.Theproblemwiththissolutionisthatthefateoftheentiremoneysystemdependsonthecompanyrunningthemint,witheverytransactionhavingtogothroughthem,justlikeabank.
Weneedawayforthepayeetoknowthatthepreviousownersdidnotsignanyearliertransactions.Forourpurposes,theearliesttransactionistheonethatcounts,sowedon'tcareaboutlaterattemptstodouble-spend.Theonlywaytoconfirmtheabsenceofatransactionistobeawareofalltransactions.Inthemintbasedmodel,themintwasawareofalltransactionsanddecidedwhicharrivedfirst.Toaccomplishthiswithoutatrustedparty,transactionsmustbepubliclyannounced,andweneedasystemforparticipantstoagreeonasinglehistoryoftheorderinwhichtheywerereceived.Thepayeeneedsproofthatatthetimeofeachtransaction,themajorityofnodesagreeditwasthefirstreceived.
3.TimestampServer
Thesolutionweproposebeginswithatimestampserver.Atimestampserverworksbytakingahashofablockofitemstobetimestampedandwidelypublishingthehash,suchasinanewspaperorUsenetpost.Thetimestampprovesthatthedatamusthaveexistedatthetime,obviously,inordertogetintothehash.Eachtimestampincludestheprevioustimestampinitshash,formingachain,witheachadditionaltimestampreinforcingtheonesbeforeit.
4.Proof-of-Work
Toimplementadistributedtimestampserveronapeer-to-peerbasis,wewillneedtouseaproofof-worksystemsimilartoAdamBack'sHashcash,ratherthannewspaperorUsenetposts.Theproof-of-workinvolvesscanningforavaluethatwhenhashed,suchaswithSHA-256,thehashbeginswithanumberofzerobits.Theaverageworkrequiredisexponentialinthenumberofzerobitsrequiredandcanbeverifiedbyexecutingasinglehash.
1inch社区将100万USDC分配至AAVE V3上借贷池赚取收益的提案已获通过:金色财经报道，据Snapshot数据显示，1inch社区将100万USDC分配至AAVE V3上借贷池赚取收益的提案已获通过，该提案计划将国库中的100万USDC资产，分配至AAVE V3上借贷池以产生被动收益，最终赞成票比例达到62%，反对票比例为37.83%，弃权票占比0.16%。[2023/5/30 11:48:31]
Forourtimestampnetwork,weimplementtheproof-of-workbyincrementinganonceintheblockuntilavalueisfoundthatgivestheblock'shashtherequiredzerobits.OncetheCPUefforthasbeenexpendedtomakeitsatisfytheproof-of-work,theblockcannotbechangedwithoutredoingthework.Aslaterblocksarechainedafterit,theworktochangetheblockwouldincluderedoingalltheblocksafterit.
Theproof-of-workalsosolvestheproblemofdeterminingrepresentationinmajoritydecisionmaking.Ifthemajoritywerebasedonone-IP-address-one-vote,itcouldbesubvertedbyanyoneabletoallocatemanyIPs.Proof-of-workisessentiallyone-CPU-one-vote.Themajoritydecisionisrepresentedbythelongestchain,whichhasthegreatestproofof-workeffortinvestedinit.IfamajorityofCPUpoweriscontrolledbyhonestnodes,thehonestchainwillgrowthefastestandoutpaceanycompetingchains.Tomodifyapastblock,anattackerwouldhavetoredotheproof-ofworkoftheblockandallblocksafteritandthencatchupwithandsurpasstheworkofthehonestnodes.Wewillshowlaterthattheprobabilityofaslowerattackercatchingupdiminishesexponentiallyassubsequentblocksareadded.
Tocompensateforincreasinghardwarespeedandvaryinginterestinrunningnodesovertime,theproof-of-workdifficultyisdeterminedbyamovingaveragetargetinganaveragenumberofblocksperhour.Ifthey'regeneratedtoofast,thedifficultyincreases.
5.Network
Thestepstorunthenetworkareasfollows:
1)Newtransactionsarebroadcasttoallnodes.
2)Eachnodecollectsnewtransactionsintoablock.
3)Eachnodeworksonfindingadifficultproof-of-workforitsblock.
4)Whenanodefindsaproof-of-work,itbroadcaststheblocktoallnodes.
5)Nodesaccepttheblockonlyifalltransactionsinitarevalidandnotalreadyspent.
6)Nodesexpresstheiracceptanceoftheblockbyworkingoncreatingthenextblockinthechain,usingthehashoftheacceptedblockastheprevioushash.
Nodesalwaysconsiderthelongestchaintobethecorrectoneandwillkeepworkingonextendingit.Iftwonodesbroadcastdifferentversionsofthenextblocksimultaneously,somenodesmayreceiveoneortheotherfirst.Inthatcase,theyworkonthefirstonetheyreceived,butsavetheotherbranchincaseitbecomeslonger.Thetiewillbebrokenwhenthenextproofof-workisfoundandonebranchbecomeslonger;thenodesthatwereworkingontheotherbranchwillthenswitchtothelongerone.
流行街头服饰品牌The Hundreds将推出元宇宙商店:金色财经报道，流行街头服饰品牌The Hundreds将在some.place上推出元宇宙商店。The Hundreds表示，虚拟商店是其在洛杉矶Fairfax社区真实商店的复刻，旨在为粉丝提供互动和社交购物体验。[2023/5/25 10:38:19]
Newtransactionbroadcastsdonotnecessarilyneedtoreachallnodes.Aslongastheyreachmanynodes,theywillgetintoablockbeforelong.Blockbroadcastsarealsotolerantofdroppedmessages.Ifanodedoesnotreceiveablock,itwillrequestitwhenitreceivesthenextblockandrealizesitmissedone.
6.Incentive
Byconvention,thefirsttransactioninablockisaspecialtransactionthatstartsanewcoinownedbythecreatoroftheblock.Thisaddsanincentivefornodestosupportthenetwork,andprovidesawaytoinitiallydistributecoinsintocirculation,sincethereisnocentralauthoritytoissuethem.Thesteadyadditionofaconstantofamountofnewcoinsisanalogoustogoldminersexpendingresourcestoaddgoldtocirculation.Inourcase,itisCPUtimeandelectricitythatisexpended.
Theincentivecanalsobefundedwithtransactionfees.Iftheoutputvalueofatransactionislessthanitsinputvalue,thedifferenceisatransactionfeethatisaddedtotheincentivevalueoftheblockcontainingthetransaction.Onceapredeterminednumberofcoinshaveenteredcirculation,theincentivecantransitionentirelytotransactionfeesandbecompletelyinflationfree.
Theincentivemayhelpencouragenodestostayhonest.IfagreedyattackerisabletoassemblemoreCPUpowerthanallthehonestnodes,hewouldhavetochoosebetweenusingittodefraudpeoplebystealingbackhispayments,orusingittogeneratenewcoins.Heoughttofinditmoreprofitabletoplaybytherules,suchrulesthatfavourhimwithmorenewcoinsthaneveryoneelsecombined,thantounderminethesystemandthevalidityofhisownwealth.
7.ReclaimingDiskSpace
Oncethelatesttransactioninacoinisburiedunderenoughblocks,thespenttransactionsbeforeitcanbediscardedtosavediskspace.Tofacilitatethiswithoutbreakingtheblock'shash,transactionsarehashedinaMerkleTree,withonlytherootincludedintheblock'shash.Oldblockscanthenbecompactedbystubbingoffbranchesofthetree.Theinteriorhashesdonotneedtobestored.
Ablockheaderwithnotransactionswouldbeabout80bytes.Ifwesupposeblocksaregeneratedevery10minutes,80bytes*6*24*365=4.2MBperyear.Withcomputersystemstypicallysellingwith2GBofRAMasof2008,andMoore'sLawpredictingcurrentgrowthof1.2GBperyear,storageshouldnotbeaproblemeveniftheblockheadersmustbekeptinmemory.
Bored Ape Yacht Club系列NFT近24小时交易额涨幅超100%:金色财经报道，据OpenSea最新数据显示，Bored Ape Yacht Club系列NFT近24小时的交易额为4671ETH，交易额涨幅达114%，近24小时交易额排名位列OpenSea第一，地板价为54.99ETH。[2023/4/17 14:07:32]
8.SimplifiedPaymentVerification
Itispossibletoverifypaymentswithoutrunningafullnetworknode.Auseronlyneedstokeepacopyoftheblockheadersofthelongestproof-of-workchain,whichhecangetbyqueryingnetworknodesuntilhe'sconvincedhehasthelongestchain,andobtaintheMerklebranchlinkingthetransactiontotheblockit'stimestampedin.Hecan'tcheckthetransactionforhimself,butbylinkingittoaplaceinthechain,hecanseethatanetworknodehasacceptedit,andblocksaddedafteritfurtherconfirmthenetworkhasacceptedit.
Assuch,theverificationisreliableaslongashonestnodescontrolthenetwork,butismorevulnerableifthenetworkisoverpoweredbyanattacker.Whilenetworknodescanverifytransactionsforthemselves,thesimplifiedmethodcanbefooledbyanattacker'sfabricatedtransactionsforaslongastheattackercancontinuetooverpowerthenetwork.Onestrategytoprotectagainstthiswouldbetoacceptalertsfromnetworknodeswhentheydetectaninvalidblock,promptingtheuser'ssoftwaretodownloadthefullblockandalertedtransactionstoconfirmtheinconsistency.Businessesthatreceivefrequentpaymentswillprobablystillwanttoruntheirownnodesformoreindependentsecurityandquickerverification.
9.CombiningandSplittingValue
Althoughitwouldbepossibletohandlecoinsindividually,itwouldbeunwieldytomakeaseparatetransactionforeverycentinatransfer.Toallowvaluetobesplitandcombined,transactionscontainmultipleinputsandoutputs.Normallytherewillbeeitherasingleinputfromalargerprevioustransactionormultipleinputscombiningsmalleramounts,andatmosttwooutputs:oneforthepayment,andonereturningthechange,ifany,backtothesender.
Itshouldbenotedthatfan-out,whereatransactiondependsonseveraltransactions,andthosetransactionsdependonmanymore,isnotaproblemhere.Thereisnevertheneedtoextractacompletestandalonecopyofatransaction'shistory.
10.Privacy
Thetraditionalbankingmodelachievesalevelofprivacybylimitingaccesstoinformationtothepartiesinvolvedandthetrustedthirdparty.Thenecessitytoannouncealltransactionspubliclyprecludesthismethod,butprivacycanstillbemaintainedbybreakingtheflowofinformationinanotherplace:bykeepingpublickeysanonymous.Thepubliccanseethatsomeoneissendinganamounttosomeoneelse,butwithoutinformationlinkingthetransactiontoanyone.Thisissimilartothelevelofinformationreleasedbystockexchanges,wherethetimeandsizeofindividualtrades,the"tape",ismadepublic,butwithouttellingwhothepartieswere.
钱包开发商Safeheron：某些多签钱包可以被使用Starknet协议的Web3应用程序攻击:金色财经报道，多方计算 (MPC) 钱包开发商Safeheron表示，某些多签钱包可以被使用Starknet协议的Web3应用程序攻击。该漏洞影响与dYdX等Starknet应用程序交互的MPC钱包。Safeheron正在与应用程序开发人员合作修补该漏洞。（Cointelegraph）[2023/3/9 12:52:37]
Asanadditionalfirewall,anewkeypairshouldbeusedforeachtransactiontokeepthemfrombeinglinkedtoacommonowner.Somelinkingisstillunavoidablewithmulti-inputtransactions,whichnecessarilyrevealthattheirinputswereownedbythesameowner.Theriskisthatiftheownerofakeyisrevealed,linkingcouldrevealothertransactionsthatbelongedtothesameowner.
11.Calculations
Weconsiderthescenarioofanattackertryingtogenerateanalternatechainfasterthanthehonestchain.Evenifthisisaccomplished,itdoesnotthrowthesystemopentoarbitrarychanges,suchascreatingvalueoutofthinairortakingmoneythatneverbelongedtotheattacker.Nodesarenotgoingtoacceptaninvalidtransactionaspayment,andhonestnodeswillneveracceptablockcontainingthem.Anattackercanonlytrytochangeoneofhisowntransactionstotakebackmoneyherecentlyspent.
TheracebetweenthehonestchainandanattackerchaincanbecharacterizedasaBinomialRandomWalk.Thesuccesseventisthehonestchainbeingextendedbyoneblock,increasingitsleadby+1,andthefailureeventistheattacker'schainbeingextendedbyoneblock,reducingthegapby-1.
TheprobabilityofanattackercatchingupfromagivendeficitisanalogoustoaGambler'sRuinproblem.Supposeagamblerwithunlimitedcreditstartsatadeficitandplayspotentiallyaninfinitenumberoftrialstotrytoreachbreakeven.Wecancalculatetheprobabilityheeverreachesbreakeven,orthatanattackerevercatchesupwiththehonestchain,asfollows:
Givenourassumptionthatp>q,theprobabilitydropsexponentiallyasthenumberofblockstheattackerhastocatchupwithincreases.Withtheoddsagainsthim,ifhedoesn'tmakealuckylungeforwardearlyon,hischancesbecomevanishinglysmallashefallsfurtherbehind.
Wenowconsiderhowlongtherecipientofanewtransactionneedstowaitbeforebeingsufficientlycertainthesendercan'tchangethetransaction.Weassumethesenderisanattackerwhowantstomaketherecipientbelievehepaidhimforawhile,thenswitchittopaybacktohimselfaftersometimehaspassed.Thereceiverwillbealertedwhenthathappens,butthesenderhopesitwillbetoolate.
Thereceivergeneratesanewkeypairandgivesthepublickeytothesendershortlybeforesigning.Thispreventsthesenderfrompreparingachainofblocksaheadoftimebyworkingonitcontinuouslyuntilheisluckyenoughtogetfarenoughahead,thenexecutingthetransactionatthatmoment.Oncethetransactionissent,thedishonestsenderstartsworkinginsecretonaparallelchaincontaininganalternateversionofhistransaction.
Therecipientwaitsuntilthetransactionhasbeenaddedtoablockandzblockshavebeenlinkedafterit.Hedoesn'tknowtheexactamountofprogresstheattackerhasmade,butassumingthehonestblockstooktheaverageexpectedtimeperblock,theattacker'spotentialprogresswillbeaPoissondistributionwithexpectedvalue:
Togettheprobabilitytheattackercouldstillcatchupnow,wemultiplythePoissondensityforeachamountofprogresshecouldhavemadebytheprobabilityhecouldcatchupfromthatpoint:
Rearrangingtoavoidsummingtheinfinitetailofthedistribution...
ConvertingtoCcode...
#includedoubleAttackerSuccessProbability(doubleq,intz)
{
doublep=1.0-q;
doublelambda=z*(q/p);
doublesum=1.0;
inti,k;
for(k=0;k<=z;k++)
{
doublepoisson=exp(-lambda);
for(i=1;i<=k;i++)
poisson*=lambda/i;
sum-=poisson*(1-pow(q/p,z-k));
}
returnsum;
}
Runningsomeresults,wecanseetheprobabilitydropoffexponentiallywithz.
q=0.1
z=0P=1.0000000
z=1P=0.2045873
z=2P=0.0509779
z=3P=0.0131722
z=4P=0.0034552
z=5P=0.0009137
z=6P=0.0002428
z=7P=0.0000647
z=8P=0.0000173
z=9P=0.0000046
z=10P=0.0000012
q=0.3
z=0P=1.0000000
z=5P=0.1773523
z=10P=0.0416605
z=15P=0.0101008
z=20P=0.0024804
z=25P=0.0006132
z=30P=0.0001522
z=35P=0.0000379
z=40P=0.0000095
z=45P=0.0000024
z=50P=0.0000006
SolvingforPlessthan0.1%...
P<0.001
q=0.10z=5
q=0.15z=8
q=0.20z=11
q=0.25z=15
q=0.30z=24
q=0.35z=41
q=0.40z=89
q=0.45z=340
12.Conclusion
Wehaveproposedasystemforelectronictransactionswithoutrelyingontrust.Westartedwiththeusualframeworkofcoinsmadefromdigitalsignatures,whichprovidesstrongcontrolofownership,butisincompletewithoutawaytopreventdouble-spending.Tosolvethis,weproposedapeer-to-peernetworkusingproof-of-worktorecordapublichistoryoftransactionsthatquicklybecomescomputationallyimpracticalforanattackertochangeifhonestnodescontrolamajorityofCPUpower.Thenetworkisrobustinitsunstructuredsimplicity.Nodesworkallatoncewithlittlecoordination.Theydonotneedtobeidentified,sincemessagesarenotroutedtoanyparticularplaceandonlyneedtobedeliveredonabesteffortbasis.Nodescanleaveandrejointhenetworkatwill,acceptingtheproof-ofworkchainasproofofwhathappenedwhiletheyweregone.TheyvotewiththeirCPUpower,expressingtheiracceptanceofvalidblocksbyworkingonextendingthemandrejectinginvalidblocksbyrefusingtoworkonthem.Anyneededrulesandincentivescanbeenforcedwiththisconsensusmechanism.
References
W.Dai,"b-money,"http://www.weidai.com/bmoney.txt,1998.
H.Massias,X.S.Avila,andJ.-J.Quisquater,"Designofasecuretimestampingservicewithminimal
trustrequirements,"In20thSymposiumonInformationTheoryintheBenelux,May1999.
S.Haber,W.S.Stornetta,"Howtotime-stampadigitaldocument,"InJournalofCryptology,vol3,no
2,pages99-111,1991.
D.Bayer,S.Haber,W.S.Stornetta,"Improvingtheefficiencyandreliabilityofdigitaltime-stamping,"
InSequencesII:MethodsinCommunication,SecurityandComputerScience,pages329-334,1993.
S.Haber,W.S.Stornetta,"Securenamesforbit-strings,"InProceedingsofthe4thACMConference
onComputerandCommunicationsSecurity,pages28-35,April1997.
A.Back,"Hashcash-adenialofservicecounter-measure,"
http://www.hashcash.org/papers/hashcash.pdf,2002.
R.C.Merkle,"Protocolsforpublickeycryptosystems,"InProc.1980SymposiumonSecurityand
Privacy,IEEEComputerSociety,pages122-133,April1980.
W.Feller,"Anintroductiontoprobabilitytheoryanditsapplications,"1957.
沙棘财经是沙棘传媒旗下专注大数据、人工智能、区块链、币圈的深度报道的垂直自媒体。微信公众号：shaji-media
郑重声明： 本文版权归原作者所有， 转载文章仅为传播更多信息之目的， 如作者信息标记有误， 请第一时间联系我们修改或删除， 多谢。